Label TextWhen this scene of urban flower sellers offering a ragged little girl a free bouquet was exhibited in New York in 1886, the reviewer doubted J.G. Brown’s accuracy. He wondered “where he [Brown] finds such self-conscious, smirking brats as are here drawn up in a row, and whether anybody has ever seen little street boys gallant to little street girls, or if such grown-up sentiment ever entered into the head or was expressed on the face of a female child in such surroundings.” Despite this carping, Brown was beloved for works like this, which featured the poor working children of New York, whose cheerful attitudes prevailed despite the harsh circumstances of their daily lives.
Brown used actual urban children for his models. He cleaned them up in his finished canvases, however, to make them picturesque, rather than squalid. He thus avoided offending his audience, who wanted sentiment, rather than documentary accuracy.
(William Keyse Rudolph, 2014)